Writer's Block: Critical mass
Apr. 9th, 2010 02:47 pm[Error: unknown template qotd]
It's all about how the criticism is presented.
First of all, context: If I ask for critique, or I'm in a situation that calls for critical feedback like a class, my job, or some sort of performance or competition, then I can accept relevant criticism as part of the deal. I like to do well at what I do so I usually take it to heart quite quickly, even if I'm initially hurt by the implication I was doing poorly before. However, I don't handle criticism well when I don't expect it. I've met a few people who take issue with this about me, saying that they can't feel obligated to *just tell me what I want to hear* and think that whenever they've got something "helpful" to say, they should say it-- but if you catch me off guard by telling me something I don't expect or want to hear, don't expect me to listen to you. In fact, expect me to put you on the blacklist of people I won't ever expose the more sensitive sides of myself to.
Second, source: If I don't know you or understand you to have any authority on the subject of what you're critiquing, I don't care to know your opinion. Under the First Amendment you're entitled to yap at me all you want, but I'm going to ignore you.
Third, manner: TACT, people. TACT. When discussing the pros and cons of complete honesty, everyone always acts like honesty has to be this brutal ego-shredding affair. There are ways to frame unpleasant information so it's more easily absorbed. If someone leads me in with a few compliments on what I did right I'm much more likely to trust them (and pay attention) when they point out what I did wrong. If you come on too strong and aggressive, I'm packing it up and high-tailing it out before you get the chance to rip my heart out and shit on it. In fact, chances are I will do exactly the opposite of what you want me to do just to be spiteful.
Depending on how invested I am, good criticism can sometimes hurt me at first but ultimately I'm gracious and usually take it to heart in order to change for the better. (Though on occasion I'll spurn even the most polite advice-- usually because after evaluating it I decide I like my way better, even if it does make for a mistake). However, when it comes to bad criticism, I don't even listen and I tend to dig my heels in and resist change just on point of principle.
I'm definitely, definitely more critical of myself than others. I hold myself to all sorts of ridiculous standards I wouldn't dream of applying to other people. I've forgiven friends for lying, abandonment, and even betrayal, but I can't forgive myself for things like having once unintentionally said something that could be construed as offensive. I've held some pretty impressive double-standards, actually, like congratulating someone on a C- while beating myself up over a B+, or telling a larger woman I think she's beautiful-- and being totally honest-- while believing I'd be intolerably ugly if I go over 130lbs.
I'm getting better about it, though; I've started not only to be easier on myself and more realistic in my personal expectations, but also to be a little more critical of other people by not just letting things slide when they offend me as I used to. I've definitely improved in the past couple of years, and it's done wonders for my stress level and self-image. Obviously I'd never want to believe I'm absolutely perfect and the world is this massive ball of ignorance that fails to appreciate me, but it was definitely unhealthy to fail to condemn people when they deserve it, especially while simultaneously beating myself up for failing to meet impossible standards.
It's all about how the criticism is presented.
First of all, context: If I ask for critique, or I'm in a situation that calls for critical feedback like a class, my job, or some sort of performance or competition, then I can accept relevant criticism as part of the deal. I like to do well at what I do so I usually take it to heart quite quickly, even if I'm initially hurt by the implication I was doing poorly before. However, I don't handle criticism well when I don't expect it. I've met a few people who take issue with this about me, saying that they can't feel obligated to *just tell me what I want to hear* and think that whenever they've got something "helpful" to say, they should say it-- but if you catch me off guard by telling me something I don't expect or want to hear, don't expect me to listen to you. In fact, expect me to put you on the blacklist of people I won't ever expose the more sensitive sides of myself to.
Second, source: If I don't know you or understand you to have any authority on the subject of what you're critiquing, I don't care to know your opinion. Under the First Amendment you're entitled to yap at me all you want, but I'm going to ignore you.
Third, manner: TACT, people. TACT. When discussing the pros and cons of complete honesty, everyone always acts like honesty has to be this brutal ego-shredding affair. There are ways to frame unpleasant information so it's more easily absorbed. If someone leads me in with a few compliments on what I did right I'm much more likely to trust them (and pay attention) when they point out what I did wrong. If you come on too strong and aggressive, I'm packing it up and high-tailing it out before you get the chance to rip my heart out and shit on it. In fact, chances are I will do exactly the opposite of what you want me to do just to be spiteful.
Depending on how invested I am, good criticism can sometimes hurt me at first but ultimately I'm gracious and usually take it to heart in order to change for the better. (Though on occasion I'll spurn even the most polite advice-- usually because after evaluating it I decide I like my way better, even if it does make for a mistake). However, when it comes to bad criticism, I don't even listen and I tend to dig my heels in and resist change just on point of principle.
I'm definitely, definitely more critical of myself than others. I hold myself to all sorts of ridiculous standards I wouldn't dream of applying to other people. I've forgiven friends for lying, abandonment, and even betrayal, but I can't forgive myself for things like having once unintentionally said something that could be construed as offensive. I've held some pretty impressive double-standards, actually, like congratulating someone on a C- while beating myself up over a B+, or telling a larger woman I think she's beautiful-- and being totally honest-- while believing I'd be intolerably ugly if I go over 130lbs.
I'm getting better about it, though; I've started not only to be easier on myself and more realistic in my personal expectations, but also to be a little more critical of other people by not just letting things slide when they offend me as I used to. I've definitely improved in the past couple of years, and it's done wonders for my stress level and self-image. Obviously I'd never want to believe I'm absolutely perfect and the world is this massive ball of ignorance that fails to appreciate me, but it was definitely unhealthy to fail to condemn people when they deserve it, especially while simultaneously beating myself up for failing to meet impossible standards.